| 1961 | | Gil Hodges |
| 1962 | Dr. Leslie Tisdall '26 | |
| 1966 | Joseph Califano, '48 | Rev. John W. Kelly, S.J. |
| 1967 | Joseph Paterno, '45 | Rev. John J. Morrison, S.J. |
| 1968 | John Powers, '30 | John Devlin
William Quinn |
| 1969 | John Hayes, '33 | Bishop Mugavero
Eamon Taylor, S.J. |
| 1970 | Rev. Robert Harris, '51 | Hugh Carey
Spec. R.J. Cronin, S.J.
W. Welch, S.J. |
| 1971 | Bob Giegengack, '25 | Bill Duffy |
| 1972 | Bill Blatty, '46 | Rev. W.T. Wood, S.J. |
| 1973 | Admiral Anderson, '23 | Walter Doolan |
| 1974 | Joseph McLaughlin, '50 | Zev Graham |
| 1975 | George Sheehan, '36 | Bill Shea |
| 1976 | John T. McNamara, '26 | "Bingo" McMahon |
| 1977 | Quinton C. Van Wynen, '28 | Rev. Fred Engel, S.J. |
| 1978 | Robert F. Coogan, '41 | Charles Winans
Spec. H.J. Oppido, S.J. |
| 1979 | John B. Hofsiss, '67 | Terrence J. Rafferty
Spec. J. J. Gerhard, S.J. |
| 1980 | Murtha Lawrence, '36 | Mrs. Mary McPhillipsy
Spec. F. A. Connor, '32 |
| 1981 | Msgr. Robert E. Fagan, '47 | William N. Burke
Franklin D. Gregory |
| 1982 | Joseph A. Healey, '47 | Rev. Jack Alexander, S.J. |
| 1983 | William P. Ford, '53 | Rev. Joseph Finnerty, S.J. |
| 1984 | Lawrence G. Pape, MD, '64 | Joseph J. Montana |
| 1985 | The Murphy Brothers '44-60' | John C. Lawn
Spec. F.J. McNamara, S.J. |
| 1986 | Cyril F. Brickfield, '37 | Rev. Lawrence B. Hill, S.J. |
| 1987 | William B. Walsh, '36 | Rev. Joseph A. Latella, S.J. |
| 1988 | Robert G. Hodson, '42 | Edward J. Bartley |
| 1989 | Rev. John T. Catoir, '49 | Frank Babinger |
| 1990 | Thomas S. Murphy, '42 | Rev. Joseph T. Watson, S.J. |
| 1991 | Thomas S. Palmeri, '56 | Rev. John L. Farrand, S.J. |
| 1992 | John E. Sexton, '59 | Rev. Raymond J. Balduf, S.J. |
| 1993 | Peter J. Gillen, '64 | Charles F. Myers |
| 1994 | Robert S. Bennett, '57 | James M. Casey, '43 - Special Recognition Award |
| 1995 | Frank G. Ziegler, '58 | Francis W. Turnbull, S.J. |
| 1996 | Fr. James Sinnott, M.M., '47 | Curtis Sliwa |
| 1997 | John R. O'Rourke, '62 | Rev. Daniel J. Berrigan, S.J. |
| 1998 | Rev. James N. Loughran, S.J., '57 | Father Rick Curry, S.J. |
| 1999 | John A. Lombardo, MD, '66 | Rev. John J. Paret, S.J. |
| 2000 | Maj. Gen. Donald C. Hilbert, '50 | Rev. William J. O'Malley, S.J. |
| 2001 | Peter T. King, '61 | Rev. Edward F. Maloney, S.J. |
| 2002 | Peter J. Gouras, '48 | Eugene A. Perry |
| 2004 | Vincent P. Quayle '57 | Rev. John J. McDonald, S.J.
Bud Roepken '53 |
| 2005 | Father Dan Fitzpatrick S.J. '53
Joe Kassis `56
Father Joe Kane, S.J. | Father Jack D. Alexander |
| 2006 | Rev. Donald J Moore '47 | John M. O'Connor |
| 2007 | Neal Scott '71
Paul O'Connor '71 | |
| 2008 | William G. Clancy '59 | |
| 2009 | Dr David Butler '57 | |
| 2010 | Hank Egan '55 | Father Gerry Reedy SJ |
| 2011 | John Dockery '62 | Jack Kaiser |
| 2012 | Thomas Hayes '60 | Rev James Keegan, SJ |
| 2013 | James Freeley '59 | His Eminence Timothy Cardinal Dolan |
| 2014 | Rev Robert F Coogan '70 | Rev Rocco C Danzi, SJ |
| 2015 | James A Fusco '62 | Sister Margaret R Smyth, O.P. |
| 2016 | William Fusco '62 | Father D. James French, SJ |
| 2017 | James J. Daly '55 | Sr. Margaret R. Smyth, O.P. |
| 2018 | C. Reynold Verret, PhD, '72 | John R. (Jack) Raslowsky II |
| 2019 | Louis A. Codispoti '58 | Peter E. Carter |
| 2020 | John LeDonne '70, | |
| 2021 | Michael Boccia '71 | Father Dan Gatti, SJ | |
| 2022 | Charles Russo '68 | Frank Comerford |
| 2023 | Ken Charles '69,
Bill Carter '67 |
